Forever A TalmidForever a Talmid tells the story of mesorah reverently handed down generation to generation. The story of the timeless rebbi talmid bond. The story of greatness in the yeshivah, the classroom, and the home and the story of the power of one mans warmth, determination, and belief in every Jew. Charlie Herzberg was a regular American boy. Fantastic third baseman, popular with his classmates, not a top student. But there were Torah scholars and leaders